BAKER STREET BABBLE
  • 221B (Home)
  • About BSB
  • Links and Such
  • Sherls on Film
  • Bookshelf

Sherlock Holmes and the Mormons

2/18/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
Anyone who's read the very first Sherlock Holmes story, A Study in Scarlet, knows that the second half of the novel deals quite extensively with a sect that, at the time, was still somewhat in its infancy: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, commonly known as the Mormons.  A Study in Scarlet was published in 1887; the Book of Mormon was first published in 1830.  So the founding of Mormonism was far closer in time to Doyle than Doyle is to modern readers.  

If you have ever met any modern day Mormons (I've met quite a few in my life), you might find the sect as described in A Study in Scarlet vastly different from the people you've experienced. Portrayed as more or less fanatical minions of Brigham Young, the Mormons in the Holmes adventure are pretty grim figures.  Hard to reconcile them with today's freshly scrubbed, shirt and tie wearing missionaries!

It's unclear to me how much research, if any, Doyle did into the sect he chose as his villains.  According to Wikipedia, Doyle's own daughter said, "... father would be the first to admit that his first Sherlock Holmes novel was full of errors about the Mormons." (One obvious example is the reference to the Angel "Merona," a misspelling of the Angel Moroni from The Book of Mormon.) However, I don't know if he was that far off base at the time, considering how different Mormons of that era were from modern Mormons. I've done a pretty considerable amount of study of Mormon history, and it's pretty clear that Joseph Smith, Brigham Young, et al, were a great deal more fanatical than their modern descendants. Smith, after all, was killed by a lynch mob, after being imprisoned for his political activity. Brigham Young led a dedicated group of Saints out to the frontier country which later became Utah, a trip on which many died.  And we've all heard about the polygamy that was common among Mormon leaders of the time.  (To be fair, the modern Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has declared that polygamy is completely incompatible with modern Church doctrine.) Doyle himself is reported to have said: "all I said about the Danite Band and the murders is historical so I cannot withdraw that, though it is likely that in a work of fiction it is stated more luridly than in a work of history." Debate still continues over A Study in Scarlet, and its depiction of Mormons.  

Picture
The article linked below is an interesting piece on the controversy, written from an ex-Mormon's point of view:
Mormons believe A Study in Scarlet is inaccurate.
According to some reports Doyle later was repentant about his treatment of the sect in his novel.  This article from The Salt Lake Tribune talks about Doyle's later dealings with the Mormons. Overall, I suppose the depiction of Latter-day Saints in A Study in Scarlet should be taken with a grain of salt. His treatment of the KKK in "The Five Orange Pips" still stands, though...

0 Comments
    Picture

    About Me

    I'm a stay-at-home dad, and Director of Music Ministries at a United Methodist Church in Mt. Juliet, TN. And a longtime fan of Sherlock Holmes.

    Archives

    September 2017
    June 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    September 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014

    Categories

    All
    Adaptations
    Amy H. Sturgis
    Animated
    A Study In Scarlet
    Basil Rathbone
    BBC
    Benedict Cumberbatch
    Ben Kingsley
    Canon
    Carl L. Heifetz
    Chronology
    Church Of Jesus Christ Of Latter-day Saints
    Comic Books
    Elementary (cbs)
    Fan Fiction
    Granada Tv
    Guy Ritchie
    Hamlet
    I Hear Of Sherlock Everywhere
    IHOSE
    Irene Adler
    Jeremy Brett
    John Gielgud
    Jonny Lee Miller
    Jude Law
    Leslie Klinger
    Lucy Liu
    Martin Freeman
    Michael Caine
    Mormons
    Musical
    Nigel Bruce
    Parody
    Pastiche
    Podcast
    Radio Adaptations
    Ralph Richardson
    Robert Downey Jr.
    Scandal In Bohemia
    Science Fiction
    Season 4
    Series 3
    Shakespeare
    Sherlock
    Sherlock (bbc)
    Sherlockian
    Solitary Cyclist
    The Abominable Bride
    The Final Problem
    The Great Game
    The Great Mouse Detective
    Vincent Starrett
    Watson
    Watson & Holmes
    Without A Clue
    W.s. Baring-gould

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • 221B (Home)
  • About BSB
  • Links and Such
  • Sherls on Film
  • Bookshelf
✕